Large, accessible coal deposits have emerged as a decisive prerequisite for extraterrestrial technological civilizations on exoplanets capable of becoming detectable beyond their home worlds.
That finding reframes cosmic silence as a geological outcome, not simply a question of biology or intelligence.
Coal and exoplanet civilization
Across Earth-like planets, the decisive evidence sits at the intersection of ancient forests, shallow seams, and the energy thresholds required to industrialize.
By tracing that chain, plant biologist Lincoln Taiz at the University of California, Santa Cruz (UCSC) documented how coal availability governed whether biological productivity ever translated into sustained technological power.
The record shows that even on worlds rich in life, coal only accumulates during rare alignments of climate, tectonics, and deep time, narrowing the window for industrial emergence.
That constraint sets up the central question ahead, how energy density and fuel accessibility determine which civilizations ever reach the point of being seen or heard.
Why aliens need coal first
An energy chain runs from buried plants to steam, steel, and eventually tools that broadcast into space.
Early on, miners can reach seams close to the surface, then use that energy to build better machines.
“Coal is critical because, based on an Earth-like geology, it is more accessible than the much deeper deposits of oil and gas.” Taiz wrote.
Oil drilling needs pipes and pumps, so a coal shortage could freeze a civilization below the energy needed to signal outward.
Coal and exoplanet energy limits
The stubborn barrier is power density, energy output per unit area, and it decides what early industry can scale.
One widely cited energy analysis quantified the limit, showing that plants capture less than 0.5% of incoming sunlight.
He also calculated that preindustrial cities needed about 20 to 30 watts per square meter, which forced fuel harvesting to sprawl outward.
Coal breaks that land limit by concentrating plant energy into tight seams, which makes engines and grids possible in one place.
Photosynthesis starts the chain
Coal starts with oxygenic photosynthesis, sunlight splits water and makes oxygen, because only that pathway built forests and a breathable sky.
On Earth, that oxygen built up slowly because oceans and rocks absorbed it, which stretched the timeline before the atmosphere changed.
Once oxygen did stay high, complex cells could get far more energy from food, which helped large plants and animals evolve.
Without that oxygen-rich atmosphere, a world might host microbes, yet it likely lacks the plants that can later become coal.
Star light controls plant growth
Astronomers look for liquid-water orbits when judging an exoplanet, a planet orbiting another star, but the review says light quality matters too.
Some stars bathe planets in the wrong mix of wavelengths, so photosynthesizers struggle to make enough chemical fuel.
A 2023 paper mapped a photosynthetic habitable zone, a narrower region where liquid water and oxygen-making photosynthesis both work.
That extra filter means a planet might keep oceans for eons and never grow the forests that later become coal.
Coal forms in wet environments
Coal begins as peat, partly decayed plant matter in wet ground, and it accumulates when water shuts down decay.
Burial adds heat and pressure, squeezing out water and gases until the material turns denser and richer in carbon.
A U.S. Geological Survey guide lays out coalification, change under heat and pressure, from peat through lignite and on to harder ranks.
Those steps take millions of years, so a planet needs long-term stable wetlands or basins to build seams worth mining.
Earth had rare coal conditions
Earth built its biggest coal stores during the Carboniferous, when swamp forests spread across the supercontinent Pangea.
Mountain building and sinking basins, driven by plate tectonics, moving crustal plates that rearrange continents, buried plant matter fast enough to survive.
Climate cycles also mattered because sea levels rose and fell, repeatedly drowning wetlands and sealing thick layers under fresh sediment.
The review treats that chain of events as hard to repeat, making huge coal reserves a rare kind of planetary luck.
Timing decides industrial success
A calendar constraint shadows the idea, with intelligence needing to arrive when coal has matured enough to power industry.
High-grade seams form slowly as burial cooks peat longer, so early thinkers could arrive before coal turns into a strong fuel.
Species do not last forever, and the authors noted that a smart lineage might vanish long before the right seams appear.
That timing problem turns coal from a simple resource into a filter that can cut down the number of detectable civilizations.
Exoplanets, coal, and alien civilization
One famous equation sits at the heart of the argument, the Drake Equation, a formula for estimating civilizations in the Milky Way.
“We therefore propose that the presence of large, readily accessible deposits of coal similar to those found on Earth would also be required to power the initial stages of industrialization on Earth-like exoplanets.” Taiz wrote.
That extra term would not judge intelligence alone, but whether geology and biology stocked accessible fuel at the right time.
Even if coal burning leaves chemical fingerprints in an atmosphere, the review warned that this phase could be brief.
Energy history sits beside biology in the hunt for alien technology, and coal becomes the key constraint in this account.
As telescopes sharpen, researchers may need to weigh light, land, and deep time together before calling any world a likely peer.
The study is published in the International Journal of Astrobiology.
—–
Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.
Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.
—–