(To clear a possible misconception: the author doesn't seem to be working with Vatican Observatory full time. Link to his profile.)
Probably the best review I read so far. The most balanced, intelligent, and open-minded, raising a few on-point objections while encouraging to follow this line of inquiry.
This is how I'd expect a real scientist (or even a skeptic) react, not the screed full of inaccuracies and poor arguments Michael Shermer wrote.
I hope he writes more on the topic.
by TypewriterTourist